Would You Ever Have Plastic Surgery To Be Glamourous?

December 2, 2009 § 2 Comments

This piece originally aired on Splicetoday.

Model Solange Magnano, Miss Argentina 1994, died on Sunday after complications from elective cosmetic surgery.

The death of the Solange Magnano reveals a host of issues related to women and images issues, beauty, and standards of appearance. Why do so many women – and men – resort to plastic surgery to be beautiful? Is there something wrong with beauty and the role of spectacular appearances?

Feminist scholars and critics, chief among them Naomi Wolf whose 1991 book The Beauty Myth: How Images of Beauty Are Used Against Women became a runaway bestseller, have argued for more relaxed beauty standards, or else have shunned fashion, ideals of beauty and makeup altogether. Why? Well, just think about it: how many times have we heard about beauty tools as harmful, uncomfortable or oppressive? For instance, Edie Sedgwick, pop-artist Andy Warhol’s Superstar, often wore five pairs of batwing eyelashes. That’s a whole lotta eyelashes! I can’t imagine that that was the most comfortable thing. But she looked fabulous, and that’s really all that matters.

Women like Edie Sedgwick who wear tons of make up, so the story goes, live under the thirsty-eye of horny men who want nothing of women but their sex. Under this theory, women can only ever be sex objects. Indeed, for many feminist critics, the whole parade of fashion is about making women subservient and appealing to men. Even Charles Baudelaire, that nineteenth-century French dandy par excellence, said in a little essay called “The Painter of Modern Life” that women should make themselves beautiful, with the aid of makeup, to be as appealing as possible to men.

Hrm? But what about gay men? What do we get out of a fabulously coiffed diva? It’s certainly not sex.

There is a difference between fashion, glamour, glitz and makeup for the fun – the theatre – of it,  and the serious issue of altering the natural state of the body with cosmetic surgery. Take, for example, the French performance artist Orlan whose cosmetic performance pieces go against the grains of our ideals of beauty. Whereas most of us would have cosmetic surgery to enhance our features, Orlan does it to purposefully deform her face. “I am against traditional notions of beauty,” the artist says.

The problem I have with most feminist critiques of beauty, and of shock-art performances like this by Orlan and others, is that they totally ignore the fun and possibility of self-creation that makeup and clothes provide. But it’s more than that: they ignore that glamour and fashion is all make-believe. Fake. Pretend. The great thing about make up is that you can wash it off. Maybe you don’t want to wear that much eye-shawdow, or whatever. Hmm. Maybe these pants do not go with that shirt. And maybe, too, you’ve grown sick of your haircut and want to try something else. The way I see it, makeup, clothes, hairstyles, shoes – whatever – are all stage props for the creation of our personas, the performances of ourselves.

Airbrushed, photoshopped or not, we should never turn to plastic surgery to make ourselves look like that magazine cover, because we know that the cover has already been doctored up. Models have a whole army of people to make them look fabulous. They have stylists, professional make-up artists, the best clothes, the best photographers, Photoshop znc airbrushing to make them look good. Have you ever seen a model without makeup? Sometimes, even they can look a little rough!  So plastic surgery should never be an option. Fashion doesn’t take itself that seriously.

Whoever said that beauty meant plastic surgery and cosmetic enhancement sure doesn’t know how to have fun with glamour. Hello! Coco Chanel practically invented costume (read: fake!) jewelry. It’s glamorous for a reason – because it’s pretend, because it’s play, because it’s a story.

We will have an easier time with beauty, fashion and glamour if we realize that we just can’t look like the magazine cover. But what we can do, though, is play with our styles, with makeup – ya’know, the non surgical, non permanent stuff! And besides, fashion changes so frequently anyway – why would we do something risky and permanent to ourselves that could go out of style be the end of the week? I know I’d rather be airbrushed!!!

Because not even Dr. Zizmor can save you when you’re dead.


Tagged: , , ,

§ 2 Responses to Would You Ever Have Plastic Surgery To Be Glamourous?

  • weddingnoise says:

    Great read. Was not familiar with Orlan until I read this post. Talk about using your body to make a statement to the world. I personally wouldn’t recommend anyway to take it that far. It would be like removing my breasts to say women shouldn’t have breast augmentation. That’s a little too far in my book.
    I noticed you made a comment on my blog. I appreciate that. In fact I have a request of you after seeing your work over at http://www.yaledailynews.com/staff/madisonmoore/.

    Friends of mine over at Exclusively Weddings are interested in being listed on your blog (or any places you write) under “Stuff I like” for the word wedding invitations. You can even write a blog post and link over to them if you like in some form or fashion.
    For your time and effort they can pay a one time fee for your trouble by Paypal. If not interested in that I’m sure their open to any other ideas you may have too.
    Look forward to hearing back from you!!

    Leslie Jenkins

  • urdead2me says:

    RIP – Solange Magnano, 38, a former Miss Argentina, wasn’t asking for world peace, or to end world hunger, or even for a cure for cancer. She just wanted a hotter ass. In comparison, a simple request, and probably easily done. Right? Wrong. http://urdead2me.wordpress.com/2009/11/29/rip-solange-magnano/

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

What’s this?

You are currently reading Would You Ever Have Plastic Surgery To Be Glamourous? at MADISON MOORE.


%d bloggers like this: